Skip to content
Plan your protein →
Dinner

High-Protein Casseroles

Missi Balison

By

ACE-MES Personal Trainer & Gym Owner

Updated
Nutrition
USDA FoodData Central

As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases.

Looking for ways to add more protein-rich staples to your diet? Try one of these casseroles! Not only are casseroles easy to make and great for feeding a crowd (hello leftovers!), but these particular recipes feature chicken, turkey, beans, eggs, tofu, seafood and cheese as their stars, so you can rest assured you’re getting your protein in.

GroupDishes
Pasta and noodle bakesTurkey Taco Casserole, Baked Ziti, Stuffed Shells Casserole, Chicken Mac and Cheese, Chicken Alfredo Bake, Tuna Noodle Casserole, Turkey Lasagna Bake, Greek Turkey Bake, Chili Mac Casserole, Pesto Pasta Bake, Peanut Noodle Bake, Tempeh Pasta Bake
Rice and grain bakesChicken Broccoli Rice Casserole, Shrimp Rice Bake, Chicken Fajita Casserole, Teriyaki Chicken Casserole, Enchilada Rice Casserole, Chicken Wild Rice Casserole, Stuffed Pepper Casserole
Potato and vegetable bakesBuffalo Chicken Bake, Loaded Potato Casserole, BBQ Chicken Casserole, Turkey Shepherd’s Pie, Salmon Potato Casserole
Cornbread, biscuit and polenta bakesCornbread-Topped Casserole, Chicken Pot Pie Casserole, Meatball Bake, Chili Cornbread Casserole
Chicken, steak and bean bakesChicken Parmesan Casserole, Salsa Verde Enchilada Casserole, Philly Cheesesteak Casserole, Chicken Parmesan Bake, Mediterranean Chicken Bake, Spinach Artichoke Chicken Bake
Breakfast casserolesBreakfast Casserole, French Toast Casserole

Pasta and noodle bakes

Turkey Taco Casserole

It’s past football season, but it’s not quite time for Thanksgiving turkey yet, so what’s a hard-working gal (exhausted from responding to all those emails!) to do? Make this easy, delicious and customizable pasta casserole (a.k.a. the casserole equivalent of a taco bar), complete with taco-seasoned ground turkey, pasta, salsa and lots of cheese. Set out bowls of shredded lettuce and plain yogurt for people to dress their pasta bowls in taco fashion. To bulk up portions, try adding in some black beans.

Baked Ziti

Yes, cottage cheese in a casserole with pasta sounds odd, but hear me out. It’s genius. The creamy ricotta (which, depending on where you live, could get pricey, and you should feel free to sub in another ricotta-esque cheese) can be traded out for an equal amount of cottage cheese (another protein source), and the lean ground beef or turkey serves as yet another source of protein. To make, stir together all ingredients and pour over the meat, top with some plain marinara sauce and bake until the edges are browned and crisp. This recipe will serve quite a few people and keep for about 3 days.

Stuffed Shells Casserole

Another super-easy recipe with minimal steps (although you will find yourself repeating said steps quite a few times)! Combine ricotta (or a combination of ricotta and cottage cheese to stretch your ricotta a little further), spinach and shredded chicken and use to stuff cooked shells.

Pour some sauce over the stuffed shells and bake until bubbly.

Chicken Mac and Cheese

Mac and cheese is comfort food, but it doesn’t always scream “protein.” Here’s how to up the protein factor: Blend or process some cottage cheese to make it extra-smooth, then use in place of some of the other ingredients that make up your favourite creamy mac and cheese sauce. Your mac will be as creamy as ever, but now with even more protein!

This one’s a winner, I promise you won’t have second helpings because it’ll be picked clean!

Chicken Alfredo Bake

Want to impress your family with a seemingly-complicated pasta dish that you didn’t spend all day on? Well, this chicken alfredo casserole is your ticket. It’s one of the easiest pasta dishes you can make, and it tastes so rich and decadent that no one will believe you when you tell them so. This alfredo is a little different from traditional alfredo because it’s made with Greek yogurt and parmesan instead of cream, and it is just as rich-tasting (at least to most palates!) and much higher in protein.

You can bulk it up with peas or green beans or broccoli, which add flavour, nutrition and bulk.

Tuna Noodle Casserole

It’s old school for a reason: tuna noodle casserole is affordable and filling. If you want to lighten things up a tad more, feel free to sub even more Greek yogurt for some of the cream. I also like to add in some peas for colour and a hint of sweetness. My family claims to “not like tuna,” but they will devour this casserole.

Light tuna canned in water and drained carries about 25.5 g of protein per 100 g, according to USDA FoodData Central.

Turkey Lasagna Bake

This lasagna-esque recipe is a cinch to make and a great option when you’re looking to feed a crowd. Simply layer your cooked zucchini or noodles with ground turkey lentil marinara sauce and bake away.

Greek Turkey Bake

When the whole group dives into this dish they’ll love the different look and feel of the orzo. If you’re looking for a protein-rich casserole that’s a little different than your run-of-the-mill red-sauce pasta, try this ground turkey orzo with feta, spinach and lemon.

Chili Mac Casserole

You can serve chili mac right on the stovetop or you can top it with cheese and bake until bubbly for a heartier dish. Either way, chili mac is hearty and filling thanks to the combo of chili and pasta. It’s also pretty adaptable, meaning you can make it with lean ground beef, beans or both, and you can play with the chili seasoning to suit your family’s spice preferences.

Pesto Pasta Bake

It’s light and flavourful! Looking for a pasta dish that isn’t tomato-based? This pesto pasta bake with chicken and peas will please all, kids included! My kids call this one “green mac and cheese,” and I wouldn’t have it any other way.

Peanut Noodle Bake

Serve with a green salad and dinner’s served! In this dish, tempeh and broccoli are baked with a peanut sauce. Baking tempeh gives it a nice chewy texture that lends itself to being eaten with a fork. This bake is another option that’s high in protein without any meat, which is great if you’re cooking for a mixed crowd of meat-eaters and vegetarians. Note: As always, please check with your guests for any food allergies or aversions before serving any dishes. Sunflower-seed butter can be used as a stand-in for peanut butter in any of the above recipes.

Tempeh Pasta Bake

Protein-rich tempeh has a slightly nutty flavour and texture that makes it a great stand-in for ground meat in dishes like meat sauce.

Similarly, tofu is another stand-in option for meat in high-protein casseroles and the like. Crumble it in a skillet (exactly like you would for meat), simmer in some marinara sauce, top with cheese and bake. Bonus points if your casserole tastes even better as leftovers! Great way to get high protein for anyone in your family who is interested!

Rice and grain bakes

Chicken Broccoli Rice Casserole

Chicken, broccoli and rice: what could go wrong? This simple recipe never disappoints and is sure to please a crowd. (Okay, that last bit was a sales pitch!) Tip: You can make this dish even easier by using store-bought rotisserie chicken and pre-cooked rice.

Tip: Greek yogurt is a lighter stand-in for a creamy sauce. Combined with a little broth, it makes a nice sauce for casseroles. Add cheddar cheese for a golden top, keeping in mind not to add too much cheese or it can make the dish a bit rich. This is a very powerful weeknight rep that also holds up for meal prep.

Shrimp Rice Bake

Another super-easy dish for busy weeknights is shrimp! Shrimp can be cooked in just a few minutes, making them a time-saver any night of the week. Serve shrimp over steamed broccoli and rice and top with a garlicky-buttery sauce and dinner’s done. Tip: You can use either raw or cooked shrimp in this recipe, but keep in mind that if you use raw shrimp, add them at the same time as everything else to ensure they cook through. Overcooked shrimp will be a bit rubbery!

Chicken Fajita Casserole

Fajita bar, from start to finish, in one pan. This quinoa fajita bake with chicken, peppers, onions and just enough cheese to hold it all together makes for a colourful casserole that scoops up nicely. Serve with avocado and salsa (on the side or on top, whatever is your call!). Tip: Quinoa (aka “small grain, big energy”) is a great source of energy and makes a wonderful base for casseroles.

Teriyaki Chicken Casserole

Love take-out but not so much the price tag? Make this Baked Teriyaki Chicken with edamame and rice! The sticky-sweet flavour is sure to please kids (and adults, too!). Leftovers make a speedy lunch bowl! Tip: Shelled edamame adds protein as well as a pop of colour to this dish. Garnish with scallions and sesame seeds before serving.

Enchilada Rice Casserole

Feeds: 6. This enchilada bake is a dinner for when you want to feed a crowd (or a family of big eaters). Black beans and ground beef provide protein while enchilada sauce and melted cheese provide plenty of flavor. To get all the flavors melded together, rice bakes right along with the rest of the ingredients. For serving, lay out bowls of chopped onion, jalapeño, and dollops of yogurt for diners to add to their plates.

Chicken Wild Rice Casserole

This casserole may look a little like your run-of-the-mill cafeteria food, but the wild rice elevates it to weekend dinner status. The wild rice has a chewy texture and nutty flavor. The mushrooms and chicken bake in a creamy sauce and soak up all of the delicious flavor.

This recipe is a real crowd pleaser. It’s got just the right amount of spice and cheese.

Stuffed Pepper Casserole

If you love stuffed peppers but hate the tediousness of filling each pepper one at a time, this is the recipe for you. This casserole tastes just like stuffed peppers, but is way easier to make (and easier to clean up, too). Rice, ground beef, tomato sauce, and peppers combine to form this flavorful casserole that’s reminiscent of stuffed peppers. Bonus: you can add in some beans to boost the protein and save a little cash.

Potato and vegetable bakes

Buffalo Chicken Bake

Buffalo Chicken Bake

If you’re a fan of buffalo wings but not a fan of being drenched in buffalo wing sauce from head to toe, this is the casserole for you. Roasted cauliflower and shredded chicken get mixed together with buffalo sauce and a creamy component (think Greek yogurt or a light cream cheese and milk blend), then baked until bubbly. Serve with some scallions sprinkled on top for additional flavor and pop of color. The roasted cauliflower adds great texture to this casserole and the creamy component tempers the spice just enough. If you’re worried it might still be too spicy for little ones (or other spice challenged eaters), cut back on the buffalo sauce just a bit.

Watch · 2 min
Portioning a high-protein casserole
Start with a protein-rich square of casserole, then add vegetables on the side so the plate is not all cheese and pasta.

Loaded Potato Casserole

Potatoes, chicken, and Greek yogurt create a creamy and hearty casserole perfect for hungry appetites. First, potatoes are cubed and roasted until golden brown, then added to a baking dish along with chicken and a creamy sauce made with cheese and Greek yogurt. This combination bakes together and gets garnished with green onions. Serves up nicely by the scoop.

BBQ Chicken Casserole

Sweet potatoes and BBQ chicken make great dinner-mates. Shredded chicken and sweet potatoes bake together in one dish with BBQ sauce. Black beans can be added in for more fiber and protein. This is an easy recipe perfect for a potluck since it travels well and is easy to reheat.

Turkey Shepherd’s Pie

If you’ve got a crew of hearty eaters on your hands, this is the casserole for you. This creamy casserole is comfort food at its finest. If you’re cooking for a group of adults and picky eaters, this is the dinner for you. Ground turkey, peas, carrots, and onions get smothered in gravy and topped with mashed potatoes. Everything bakes together until the mashed potatoes are golden brown and the edges are nice and crispy.

Salmon Potato Casserole

Potatoes, salmon, and dill create a comforting casserole that’s anything but complicated. Use any flavor of already cooked salmon (preferably store bought since that way you’ll have a lot more free time). Try using leftover baked salmon if you happen to have some!

Layers of potato and salmon combine with just the right amount of seasoning (so that you can still add a squeeze of lemon if desired) and bake together in the oven. On cold nights when you want to make dinner for a lot of people, this is the recipe to pull out.

Cornbread, biscuit and polenta bakes

Cornbread-Topped Casserole

This baking dish casserole has two components: a seasoned mix of chicken, corn, black beans and a light sauce topped with cornbread batter. It’s baked until golden brown and heated through. The cornbread topping makes it perfect for potlucks since it slices and travels nicely.

Chicken Pot Pie Casserole

Creamy sauce, vegetables, and shredded chicken bake together in one dish and are topped with biscuits. This chicken pot pie casserole skips the hassle of making individual pot pies and the fussiness of working with pie dough. This casserole is perfect for a dinner party since it bakes in one dish and isn’t greasy at all.

Meatball Bake

Polenta sets up firm once it’s cooked, making it perfect for this hearty casserole. Cooked polenta gets topped with meatballs and marinara, then mozzarella cheese. This hearty casserole is like a pasta dish you can feel good about eating! This casserole bakes together into one big, crowd feeding meal. That makes this a hearty dish that will keep you full.

Chili Cornbread Casserole

Feeds: 8. Ready to feed a crowd? This hearty turkey chili recipe has three types of beans to make it even more filling and protein packed. This easy turkey chili is baked in a casserole dish and topped with cornbread before baking. Feed the crowd and count on having leftovers (they’re delicious!).

Bake until the cornbread is set and the chili is bubbly at the edges. This makes a LOT of chili-cornbread casserole. You’ll wish you’d made double!

Chicken, steak and bean bakes

Chicken Parmesan Casserole

Craving chicken parmesan but don’t feel like standing over the stove flipping cutlets? Try this one pan dinner that still has all the chicken parmesan goodness! Use baked breaded chicken (or even chopped oven baked tenders), then add marinara and mozzarella on top and bake till done. Serve over pasta or roasted vegetables. This is a great dish to make when you’re hosting since it comes out the same every time.

Salsa Verde Enchilada Casserole

This is what I make when the fridge looks empty but I still need dinner to do some actual work. Layers of shredded chicken, white beans, tortillas, and salsa verde get baked together into one Tex-Mex casserole.

Everyone will ask for seconds, and the white beans lend some much needed protein to this recipe (trust us), especially with the fresh lime juice at the end.

Philly Cheesesteak Casserole

If you love cheesesteaks, this casserole is for you! Lean ground beef gets browned in a skillet, then sauteed peppers and onions get added in. Serve over rice, over roasted potatoes, or over rolls to really recreate that cheesesteak vibe. This recipe easily doubles or triples to make even more!

Kale, Chicken, and White Bean Bake

This casserole may look like it’s just kale and cheese, but there’s shredded chicken and white beans in there too!

The Parmesan baked on top of this kale, chicken, and white bean casserole is salty and crunchy, and is absolutely crucial to the dish! Make this on a Sunday when you’re batch cooking, the flavors only get better when refrigerated overnight.

Mediterranean Chicken Bake

This is the baked casserole that won’t bog you down, a wonderful change of pace that manages to be so bright and fresh!

This chicken and chickpea casserole is full of flavor, but not spicy at all, perfect for a dish you’re making for company! Chicken and chickpeas both provide protein, and the tomatoes and olives have a salty-sweet Mediterranean influence. Tip: If you’d like to top with feta after baking, the texture will be tangy and creamy versus melted into the sauce.

Spinach Artichoke Chicken Bake

This rich casserole tastes more like a dip with spinach and artichoke hearts, but it’s chicken that makes this casserole a full meal. Serve with a green salad on the side. Depending on how hungry people are, serve with bread, rice, or pasta on the side as well.

Breakfast casseroles

Breakfast Casserole

Not every casserole has to be a dinner situation: breakfast-for-a-crowd is a real flex, especially on busy weekends. In a bowl, whisk together eggs and some of the milk. Add veggies and sausage and stir to combine. Bake until set.

Serve by the scoop. Serve with hot sauce on the side (pass the bottle so everyone can control how much they want!). These make great individual portions for quick lunches, meal prep, or brunch.

French Toast Casserole

This is for those of you out there that want something cozy without a sugar crash an hour later on. This one pan dinner is loaded with protein from eggs and a Greek yogurt sauce! Try using higher-protein bread! It may not seem like a weeknight meal, but this egg bake is so good and easy that it definitely is one!

Meal Prep Gear I Use

Casserole night just got 3 times easier, from baking to serving to devouring those leftovers.

Ingredient protein figures are based on USDA FoodData Central. How we calculate nutrition.

Personal trainer and gym owner · Writes recipes and meal ideas on Athletic Lift

Missi Balison is a personal trainer, gym owner, and licensed massage therapist in Sandpoint, Idaho, and an ACE certified Medical Exercise Specialist with 26 years in health and fitness. Most of her clients at Missi Balison Fitness, the studio she has owned since 2013, are women over 40 working on strength, weight loss, and nutrition. On Athletic Lift she writes recipes and meal ideas and makes the videos in them. As a Platinum-level Amazon Influencer, she tests the kitchen tools and high-protein staples she recommends.