Skip to content
Plan your protein →
Snacks & Sides

Game Day Snacks

Missi Balison

By

ACE-MES Personal Trainer & Gym Owner

Updated

As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases.

I usually end up hosting on game day, which means I’m the one staring into the fridge an hour before kickoff. I want food people will eat, and I train too much to eat only junk food all day. So this spread leans on protein and holds up on the counter for up to 2 hours at a time. None of it needs constant attention.

The spread is grouped by when each snack hits the table: cold things first, then the oven, then the stove and grill, with two that sit warm for the whole game.

Out before kickoff

    These can be made ahead and served cold or at room temperature, so I’d set these out first.

    Cowboy Caviar

    Cowboy caviar

    Black Bean Dip. The black beans and large amount of vegetables give this some fiber and a little plant protein. It’s got a nice crunch to it, too. It’s best served with chips or spooned over grilled chicken later in the day. This can be made first and will get better as it sits, but it should be kept in the refrigerator and not sit out more than 2 hours.

    Chips, Salsa, and Guacamole

    Chips and dip. What game day buffet would be complete without chips and dip? I like to serve freshly made guacamole with a bright mango salsa on the side. These don’t have a ton of protein, but will help fill people up in between other protein filled bites. Have plenty of these available. This will fill people up a little, but is not as heavy as some of the other fare.

    Cheese Ball Bites

    Mini cheese balls. Rather than making a big cheese ball that no one wants to break apart, I make mini cheese balls. They’re already breaded and ready to go and people can grab them. These are a little richer, so I like to serve them with a crisper food like a veggie tray. You can roll these up a day ahead of time and serve cold.

    Salami and Goat Cheese Bites

    Salami and goat cheese skewers. Thread salami, goat cheese, and an olive onto a pick. These can be whipped up in about 5 minutes and include salty, creamy, and briny all in one bite. There’s a little protein here from the salami and cheese. I like to make a big tray of these to have ready. Keep these cold until it’s time to serve.

    Tomato Bruschetta

    Bruschetta. Rather than a bunch of cheesy, fried foods, I also like to serve bruschetta. It’s made with fresh chopped tomatoes, basil, and garlic over toasted bread. Rather than assembling bruschetta ahead of time and having everything get soggy, I like to serve the chopped topping in a bowl and let people add as much or as little as they want on the toast. That way the bruschetta stays fresh and crisp.

    Charcuterie Board

    Meat and cheese board. While all of the other food is getting made, a charcuterie board is a great option to have laid out. I fill mine with a couple different cured meats and cheeses and any combination of crackers and fruit that I have on hand. The meats and cheeses are pretty high in protein so people can graze on these and feel pretty full. Start with a large cutting board and fill in the gaps as you go.

      Veggie Tray with Dip

      Veggie tray. A veggie tray is nice to have some fresh, crisp, crunchy fare available. I like to serve a veggie tray with a dip like Greek yogurt ranch that will bump up the protein a little. These can be cut up ahead of time and are one of the easiest appetizers to have ready.

      Hot from the oven

      These will require the use of your oven.

      Buffalo Chicken Dip

      This is loaded with shredded chicken so it’s higher in protein than the typical chips and cheese appetizer and will fill people up. I like to serve this with celery and peppers. Bake this until it’s browned and then keep it warm so it’s still scoopable later in the day.

      Spinach Artichoke Dip

      Spinach artichoke dip

      This has great flavor and texture. Spinach and artichoke dip. I love a good, warm, cheesy spinach and artichoke dip. I like to add a little Greek yogurt instead of using all sour cream, which will bump up the protein a bit without sacrificing too much flavor. This is good served with toasted bread or cucumber rounds to keep it a little lighter. This also can easily be made the day ahead of time and reheated. These appetizers are easy to reheat later in the evening, if necessary.

      Bacon Cheese Fries

      Loaded fries. Who doesn’t love a good loaded fry? Loaded fries are made with bacon and cheddar over a crispy bed of fries. These by themselves are not the highest in protein, so I like to serve these with some of the other higher-protein appetizers to help balance out the buffet. Rather than frying the potatoes, bake and broil them, and they’ll still be crispy. Serve these hot just before the game starts.

      Ham and Cheese Sliders

      Ham and cheese sliders

      Baked ham and Swiss sliders. Twelve fit into one baking pan! These are made with soft rolls brushed with butter and packed with ham and Swiss and baked until golden brown. These little sliders are packed with protein and full of flavor.

      BBQ Chicken Flatbread

      BBQ chicken flatbread. When feeding a lot of people I find that one or two large pizzas just isn’t going to cut it, but making a few of these BBQ chicken flatbreads will! These are loaded with barbecue sauce, red onions, and tons of shredded chicken for a protein-packed appetizer that everyone will love. These are great served warm or even at room temperature. The flatbreads are baked until the edges are nice and crispy and cut into long strips.

      Stuffed Mushrooms

      Stuffed mushrooms

      Cheesy herby baked stuffed mushrooms. These cheesy herby stuffed mushrooms are quick and easy to throw together, but taste and look like you slaved over them! Mushrooms are loaded with a herby, cheesy mixture and baked until bubbly and golden brown. Make these on the smaller side and they will go a long way, one pan will serve quite a few people!

      Loaded Baked Potatoes

      Loaded potatoes. Loaded potatoes are the ultimate comfort food appetizer! Potatoes are baked until the skin is crispy and split and loaded with cheese, bacon, and any other fixin’s you might have on hand. Leftover pulled pork would be great added to these and would make them into more of a meal. Serve these while they are still warm!

      Air Fryer French Fries

      Fries in the air fryer can be prepared in a short time. These are not the highest in protein, so I serve these along with some other higher-protein appetizers, but these are sure to please! Be sure to get these on the table while they are still hot, sprinkle on some salt as soon as they are out of the oven!

        Cheddar Bay Biscuits

        Cheddar drop biscuits. Warm, cheesy cheddar drop biscuits are a must have in my house on game day! These are loaded with cheddar and baked until golden brown and slathered with garlic butter.

        Off the stove or grill

        These will require the use of your stovetop and/or grill. These are best served warm and bite sized, no fork necessary! These appetizers are best served right off of the stove or grill! These are also great because they can be served hot or cold and can be reheated without drying out!

        Smash Burger Sliders

        Mini smash cheese burgers. My family absolutely loves these mini smash cheese burgers! The burgers are seared until crispy on the outside and are beefy enough to count as a meal in and of themselves! Topped with cheese and onions, everyone can top their own! Make a double batch of these, they will not last long!

        BBQ Chicken Drumsticks

        Sticky BBQ drumsticks. If you are looking for an appetizer that is packed with protein, then look no further than these sticky BBQ drumsticks! Drumsticks are packed with a dry rub and grilled until cooked through and crispy. Barbecue sauce is brushed on during the last couple of minutes of cooking to prevent it from burning. These drumsticks can be devoured with one hand, making them the perfect game day appetizer! Serve these on a platter with lots of napkins!

        From a safety standpoint, chicken on the grill is done at 165°F, the FSIS minimum for poultry.

        Chicken Quesadillas

        Chicken quesadillas. These quesadillas are filled with tons of cheese and seasoned chicken and are crispy and full of flavor! These are seared until crispy and golden brown and then cut into wedges to make them easier to share. A stack of these will feed those guests who are hungry for more than just chips! Make these up ahead of time and warm them up in the oven before serving.

        Black Bean Tacos

        Vegetarian tacos. Not everyone is a fan of meat, so I like to always have at least one vegetarian option! The black beans bring fiber and plant protein, and the charred tortillas elevate these tacos from a side to a main. These vegetarian tacos are quick and easy to make and are perfect for when you are running out of time! Set these out with all of the fixin’s so your guests can build their own.

        Blistered Shishito Peppers

        Sautéed shishito peppers. If you are looking for an easy appetizer to make while everything else is in the oven, then these sautéed shishito peppers are for you! All you need is a hot pan, some oil, and a few minutes! Shishito peppers are blistered until softened and lightly charred. These are sprinkled with flaky salt and a squeeze of lemon before serving. Most of these peppers are pretty mild, but the occasional one packs a punch!

        Sausage and Peppers

        Sausage and peppers

        Skillet sausage and peppers. These skillet sausage and peppers are great served by themselves or stuffed into a roll! Sausage, peppers, and onions are sautéed until the sausage is browned and the peppers and onions are sweet and soft. Serve these up while they are still warm or keep them warm in a slow cooker if you will be serving these throughout the game. These are the two game day appetizers I make the most!

          Kept warm through the game

          These can be made ahead and kept warm during the game. These can be made up ahead of time and sliced and served family style. These can be made ahead of time and will hold up really well for re-warming. These appetizers can be made ahead and served family style!

          Watch · 2 min
          How much food to put out
          A per-guest protein starting point, why one protein-forward dish like meatballs matters next to the chips and dips, and what to make ahead.

          Cocktail Meatballs

          Meatballs. Meatballs make a hearty appetizer because they are loaded up with protein and will keep your guests full! Serve these meatballs in a bowl with toothpicks next to it! To make these meatballs ahead of time, roll them up and bake them the night before!

          Pulled Pork Sliders

          Pulled pork. I almost always make pulled pork for my game day appetizer spread! The shoulder is slow cooked until fork tender and falls apart easily. Served with toppings and buns, your guests can make their own sandwiches! Pulled pork is a cheap way to feed a crowd and is loaded with protein! Any leftovers can be repurposed into tacos the next day!

          Meal Prep Gear I Use

          Two things that get the most use when this spread is on the counter.

            Personal trainer and gym owner · Writes recipes and meal ideas on Athletic Lift

            Missi Balison is a personal trainer, gym owner, and licensed massage therapist in Sandpoint, Idaho, and an ACE certified Medical Exercise Specialist with 26 years in health and fitness. Most of her clients at Missi Balison Fitness, the studio she has owned since 2013, are women over 40 working on strength, weight loss, and nutrition. On Athletic Lift she writes recipes and meal ideas and makes the videos in them. As a Platinum-level Amazon Influencer, she tests the kitchen tools and high-protein staples she recommends.