Skip to content
Plan your protein →
Dinner

Fall Casseroles

Missi Balison

By

ACE-MES Personal Trainer & Gym Owner

Updated

As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases.

As soon as it gets cold out I get my oven going! I love one-pot oven dinners when I’m busy, they allow me to do other things while dinner cooks (like PT recovery work lol). Here are my favorite high protein casseroles & oven dinners!

GroupDishes
Pasta and rice dishesBaked Ziti, Baked Feta Pasta, Cheeseburger Casserole, Classic Beef Lasagna, Baked Mac and Cheese, Butternut Squash Risotto, Tuna Noodle Casserole
Layered and stuffed mainsChicken Pot Pie, Enchilada Casserole, Shepherd’s Pie, Loaded Baked Potatoes, Stuffed Peppers, Cheesy Chicken and Spinach Bake, King Ranch Chicken Casserole
Roasts and meatloafCracker Barrel Meatloaf, Pot Roast, Roasted Chicken, Roasted Pork Loin
Sides and startersPotatoes au Gratin, Baked Beans, Green Bean Casserole, Stuffed Mushrooms
Egg bakesEverything Bagel Breakfast Casserole, Egg Bake

Pasta and rice dishes

Baked Ziti

Baked ziti: My go to casserole when I need to feed a crowd but still need to hit my protein goals. To increase the protein I’ll add a little extra ground beef and ricotta to the sauce so it’s not just a boat load of melted cheese! It also reheats great so Monday’s dinner can double as Tuesday’s lunch!

    When reheating a casserole, heat it to 165°F, the safe internal temperature USDA FSIS sets for leftovers and casseroles.

    Baked Feta Pasta

    Baked feta pasta

    This pasta uses the viral baked feta technique where the whole block of feta is baked down with the tomatoes to make a creamy sauce. The chicken and feta together make this high in protein & filling. Only takes about 20 minutes hands free oven time too!

    Watch · 2 min
    Making a casserole a balanced plate
    Put a protein-heavy portion of casserole on the plate first, then add a vegetable side for volume and fiber.

    Cheeseburger Casserole

    Cheeseburger casserole

    This casserole has all the flavor of a cheeseburger minus the time at the grill! Lean ground beef, pasta & cheese all baked together for a dinner even picky eaters will devour. I always try to use 90/10 ground beef to keep the protein high and the fat lower. Great for those week nights when it’s dark at 6pm and everyone’s hungry!

      Classic Beef Lasagna

      This is a good one to make on the weekends because it will last 3-4 days! Lean ground beef and ricotta cheese mixed with cottage cheese make this lasagna super protein filled in every bite (not just cheese and noodles)! It’s a bit more work to put together but definitely worth it to feed a crowd or one hungry weight lifter! Pro tip: make sure to let your lasagna rest for about 15 min after you take it out of the oven or it won’t be as easy to slice!

      Baked Mac and Cheese

      I love this recipe because it shows you how to still get protein with mac & cheese! Cottage cheese mixed into the sauce (along with other cheeses) gives this casserole some extra protein but also makes it super creamy. Add some shredded chicken or diced ham to turn it into a full dinner. Baking it browns the top and really brings out the flavors, don’t skip this step!

      Butternut Squash Risotto

      Risotto is delicious but also usually takes forever to make. Using an instant pot for this recipe takes the tedium out of making it for a weeknight dinner. Butternut squash really makes it taste like fall! Add some shredded chicken or extra parmesan to turn this dish from just carbs into something filling. Creamy but without using tons of cream! This one tastes like comfort food but isn’t as heavy as you might think!

      Tuna Noodle Casserole

      Tuna noodle casserole is an old-school dish built on a cheap pantry protein. Canned tuna provides the protein, and I lighten the sauce so it does not feel like a brick before a workout. This recipe can come together quick! Just have some canned goods on hand and you can make it with hardly any fresh ingredients!

      Layered and stuffed mains

      Chicken Pot Pie

      Chicken pot pie

      I like to thin out the pie a bit from some diner inspired recipes so that it doesn’t feel too rich before a workout. Definitely a meal though! Let the casserole cool for a few minutes so it’s easier to slice!

      Enchilada Casserole

      Enchilada casserole

      The shredded chicken gives this casserole some extra protein. These enchiladas are baked instead of rolled to save a step! Layering tortillas, ground beef or shredded chicken & enchilada sauce gives you a high protein casserole. I try to limit the amount of cheese so it still gets a little crispy but doesn’t drown out the filling. Serve in squares for easy portion control!

      Shepherd’s Pie

      This one is for those super cold workouts! Protein packed ground lamb or beef layered with seasoned mashed potatoes. I like to add a little greek yogurt to my mashed potatoes to bump up the protein even more. Bake until the top is golden!

      Loaded Baked Potatoes

      Add some toppings to a baked potato & you’ve got a meal! I like to scoop mine out & add shredded chicken, cheese & greek yogurt (instead of sour cream to up the protein a bit). Great option because they’re pretty much hands off cooking while you do everything else! These are always a hit with the family because everyone can pile on their own toppings!

        Stuffed Peppers

        Stuffed peppers

        Stuffing ground beef or turkey & rice into peppers makes it easy to portion out! Make sure you brown your meat & season it well before stuffing! I like to bake them just long enough to get a little char on the top. They also reheat well & will last you for a few days! I like to season mine extra well so the skin gets nice & crispy!

        Cheesy Chicken and Spinach Bake

        This is a great recipe to add some flavor to chicken breast. It’s a super easy casserole that will get nice & brown on top but still leave the chicken juicy on the bottom. Lean protein & not super rich with the addition of the spinach!

        King Ranch Chicken Casserole

        This casserole is a little bit different from your traditional recipe! Layering shredded chicken, tortillas & seasoned sauce will leave you with a rich but not too filling casserole. Cut in squares & you’ve got 3-4 days worth of high protein dinners!

        Roasts and meatloaf

        Not casseroles!

        Cracker Barrel Meatloaf

        This meatloaf recipe bakes up nice & juicy & isn’t dry like some meatloaves can be. Lean beef mixed with just an egg & some oats instead of a ton of breadcrumbs. Leftovers make for some great sandwiches! I like to top mine off with a tangy glaze! Guaranteed to satisfy & protein dense!

        Pot Roast

        Pot roast

        Pot roast is the ultimate winter recipe! Just sear the chuck roast (I like to sear mine really well for extra flavor in the pot), chuck it in the oven & let the magic happen. Slice & serve with some of the delicious juices it’s cooked in! Leftovers last for a few days!

        Roasted Chicken

        Roasted chicken is the perfect mix of minimal effort & a whole lot of flavor & protein! One chicken can provide meat for 2-3 recipes. Eat the first meal straight from the bird with the crispy skin & then use the leftovers shredded in bowls, on salads, etc. Roasting a whole chicken can provide protein for 3-4 busy days!

        Roasted Pork Loin

        This recipe calls for roasting broccoli & cauliflower on the same tray as the pork loin! Lean protein & vegetables & minimal dishes! Sear first then roast! Let the pork loin rest before slicing to make sure it stays juicy!

        Sides and starters

        Alongside your main!

        Potatoes au Gratin

        These potatoes are perfect next to a roast or chicken. The addition of a little extra cheese & some cottage cheese bumps up the protein content in these thin sliced potatoes baked in a creamy sauce! Great next to grilled proteins!

          Baked Beans

          Baked beans read like a cookout side, but they carry more protein than people give them credit for. I bake mine low & slow & add some chunks of lean turkey or ham to up the protein! Smoky, sweet & great next to grilled proteins. Make a big batch, these beans are even better the next day!

          Green Bean Casserole

          This is my go to recipe for green bean casserole during the fall. Lightly sweet & a bit crisp on top but still creamy. Add some diced up ham or turkey to increase the protein!

          Stuffed Mushrooms

          These mushrooms have a side of protein with the addition of some sausage & cheese! My family loved these as an appetizer but I also think they’d make a great side dish. Ready in 20 minutes!

          Egg bakes

          Perfect for breakfast or dinner! Slice into squares & grab for an on the go breakfast or dinner!

          Everything Bagel Breakfast Casserole

          Everything bagel breakfast casserole

          This is a super protein dense casserole. This recipe bakes eggs & cheese with some seasoning & leaves you with a protein dense casserole you can slice into squares! I like to make this on Sundays & it lasts us 3-5 days for breakfast or dinner! Great cold straight out of the fridge!

          Egg Bake

          Easy weeknight recipe while your main protein is resting! This recipe combines eggs, cheese & any veggies you want to use up! Makes for the easiest meal prep for 3-5 days. A year round recipe!

            Personal trainer and gym owner · Writes recipes and meal ideas on Athletic Lift

            Missi Balison is a personal trainer, gym owner, and licensed massage therapist in Sandpoint, Idaho, and an ACE certified Medical Exercise Specialist with 26 years in health and fitness. Most of her clients at Missi Balison Fitness, the studio she has owned since 2013, are women over 40 working on strength, weight loss, and nutrition. On Athletic Lift she writes recipes and meal ideas and makes the videos in them. As a Platinum-level Amazon Influencer, she tests the kitchen tools and high-protein staples she recommends.