Skip to content
Plan your protein →
Dinner

Holiday Main Dishes

Skylar Macall

By

NASM Certified Personal Trainer

Updated

As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases.

If there’s one thing hosting a holiday meal for 14 taught me, it’s this: Pick a main that won’t make you crazy. Protein first, always. When I host, I go with proteins that are lean, easy to make enough of and that can hold up (meaning: will reheat well and/or can be kept hot without drying out). Here are my go-tos:

Roasted in the oven

Classic Roast Turkey

Turkey: I dry brine mine (basically just salt and herbs rubbed on the turkey and left uncovered in the fridge for 2 days, which ensures crisp skin and eliminates the need to baste) and roast it. A 14-pound bird will serve 12 with leftovers. Tip: Give it 30 minutes to rest before carving, allowing the juices to redistribute instead of running out when you make the first cut.

Prime Rib Roast

    Prime rib: Okay, this isn’t technically lean, but it’s splurge meat I make once a year and we have slices of rosy prime rib with horseradish cream for Sunday dinner, too. Roasted low and slow with a high-heat finish at the end, it’s simple and delicious. Buy about 1 pound per person. Note: This one has to be bone-in.

    Pepper-Crusted Beef Tenderloin

    Tenderloin: Beef tenderloin is expensive, yes, but lean, yes, and it’s easy to serve slices of it to a crowd, yes. To make, I tie it, then give it a heavy pepper bark (basically just smash cracked pepper on and all over it), then sear and roast at 425°F to an internal temperature of 125°F. It’s done in less than an hour, which gives me more time than if I made the prime rib.

    Herb Stuffed Porchetta

    Porchetta: This one isn’t lean, but I make it because it looks like I spent days on it when I spent less than an hour. Basically I’m rolling up herbs, garlic and fennel in a pork loin, then tying it and roasting it until crackly. Serves lots of people, and slices of porchetta sautéed in a sauté pan the next day are great with eggs for brunch.

    Lemon Herb Roast Chicken

    Chicken: This is my option when I want something easy and quick. I roast two birds at the same time (stuffed with lemon, garlic and thyme, and make gravy from the drippings!), which will serve 8 in about an hour and a half. Bonus: You can apportion chicken parts according to strength (arms) and taste (legs)—I give the kids thighs and the big appetites get breast.

      Herb-Crusted Pork Tenderloin

      Pork tenderloin: Not expensive, and a great option when you’re trying to save a couple dollars. They take only 20 minutes in a 425°F oven, so you can make 3 or 4 for a crowd. I give them a light herb bark to give them flavor and color without the fuss of making a sauce. Yes, one of the leanest proteins you can serve.

      Sheet Pan Salmon with Tapenade

      Salmon: I make one big side of salmon (enough for everyone to have a piece—no, they won’t eat the whole thing, but it’s a good option to have, especially if there are vegetarians in the crowd who will gobble up the roasted veg that come out with it). Fish with tapenade: Roasted fish with tapenade is about as simple as mains get. I like it because it 1) appeals to people who don’t eat red meat, 2) has protein plus healthy fat, and 3) makes great leftover fish salad! How: Spread tapenade over the fish and roast at 400 degrees for 15 minutes. Serve from the sheet pan.

      Oven Kalua Pork

      This one takes a bit of forethought, but it’s basically hands off from there, freeing you to do other things while it cooks. Pork shoulder: Basically I rub it down with sea salt and liquid smoke and leave it to cook in the oven on low all day. Shredded, it makes salty, smoky pulled pork. Serve it on slider buns or over rice.

      Smoked or grilled

      Smoked Turkey

      Run the smoker at 275°F and pull the bird when the thigh hits 165°F. Smoked turkey: I like this because 1) you get turkey sandwiches made with shredded leftover smoked turkey (which is full of protein!), and 2) you free up the oven so you can focus on side dishes. Plus, it tastes smoky in a way roasted turkey can’t achieve.

      Watch · 2 min
      Building the plate around the main
      The roast is your protein. Fill the rest of the plate with vegetables and everyone leaves full.

      Surf and Turf Platter

      Steak and lobster: Okay, so I know this isn’t a braise, but it’s basically hands-off once it hits the grill or broiler. I grill a couple of strip steaks (thick-cut), and broil the lobster tails (about 8 minutes), and carve everything family-style. Serves lots of people, and no one can complain about not having enough meat because there are two on one platter.

        Smoked Brisket

        Brisket: A whole packer brisket will feed 15 with slices to spare, and it’s a great source of protein for the price. I smoke mine overnight, wrapping it partway through, then let it rest a few hours in a cooler while I do other things.

        Grilled Tri-Tip

        Tri-tip: I rub it with a basic seasoning mix and grill it for about 30 minutes to medium rare. I slice it thin and against the grain for tenderness. Will you get more protein for your dollar than with most roasts?

        Braised low and slow

        Simmered for hours in liquid, and the short ribs are braised the day before.

        Braised Short Ribs

        Short ribs: I make these the day before (braising them in red wine), and chill them overnight. I skim off the congealed fat (see? easy!) before gently rewarming them. Serve over mashed potatoes with braising liquid spooned over the top. Note: These get even better on day 2—don’t believe me? Try them.

        Beef Bourguignon

        Beef bourguignon

        Beef bourguignon: This is what I make when it’s cold outside and the guest list keeps growing. Chuck roast, mushrooms and pearl onions simmered in red wine for 3 hours until tender—easily doubled in a big Dutch oven, and can keep on the stovetop as long as you want. Full of protein? You bet.

        Classic Pot Roast

        Cheap? Feeds lots of people, too. These are the easiest, no-fuss, throw-it-all-in-the-oven-and-forget-it kind of crowd feeders. Chuck roast: Chuck roast, onions and carrots at 300 degrees for 4 hours and you’ve got fork tender roast beef that’s great shredded over veggies for tacos, burritos and beef bowls over the next 3 to 4 days. Or use the same basic recipe in your slow cooker to free up the oven.

        Baked in a dish

        Baked Ziti

        Filling? Yes. Baked ziti: The ultimate make ahead pasta, assembled two days before and baked just before dinner time. The ricotta and lean ground beef bump up the protein content. This recipe fills a 9×13 baking dish and feeds 8 people—so I double it.

          Chicken Pot Pie

          Chicken pot pie: A true crowd pleaser, and freezes well. I make mine in a 9×13 dish and layer it with plenty of shredded chicken for added protein. Assemble it the day before and pop it in the oven when your guests show up—the crust will be golden when they’re ready to eat.

          Cracker Barrel Style Meatloaf

          Cracker barrel style meatloaf

          Meatloaf: I make two loaves of lean glazed meatloaf, which the kids always love. It carves nicely for a buffet and reheats beautifully. Leftovers: meatloaf sandwiches—always a holiday tradition in my house.

          Shepherd’s Pie

          Shepherd’s pie: This is a great option for smaller groups. Basically ground beef (or lamb), braised with vegetables, topped with mashed potatoes and baked till golden. Make it the day before and bake it when you’re ready (yes, even straight from the fridge). Packed with protein thanks to that beefy layer.

          Chicken Enchilada Casserole

          Enchilada casserole

          Chicken enchilada casserole: Shredded chicken, tortillas, black beans, enchilada sauce and cheese make up this casserole that I assemble Christmas Eve in a big baking dish. It bakes up in about 40 minutes (at 375 degrees) and slices into pretty little squares for the buffet table.

            Online fitness coach · Writes recipes and meal ideas on Athletic Lift

            Skylar Macall is an online fitness coach based in Utah, a NASM Certified Personal Trainer (NASM-CPT), and a High Fitness certified instructor. A former Division I rugby player, she writes recipes and meal ideas on Athletic Lift and makes the videos in them.